“What do you call a dog that is incontrovertibly true? Dogma”: Testing LLM Generalization through Humor

Abstract

Humor, requiring creativity and contextual understanding, is a hallmark of human intelligence, showcasing adaptability across linguistic scenarios. While recent advances in large language models (LLMs) demonstrate strong reasoning on various benchmarks, it remains unclear whether they truly adapt to new tasks like humans (i.e., generalize) or merely replicate memorized content. To explore this, we introduce Phunny, a new humor-based question-answering benchmark designed to assess LLMs’ reasoning through carefully crafted puns. Our dataset is manually curated to ensure novelty and minimize data contamination, providing a robust evaluation of LLMs’ linguistic comprehension. Experiments on pun comprehension, resolution, and generation reveal that most LLMs struggle with generalization, even on simple tasks, consistently underperforming the human baseline. Additionally, our detailed error analysis provides valuable insights to guide future research.