Forest for the Trees: Overarching Prompting Evokes High-Level Reasoning in Large Language Models

Abstract

Chain-of-thought (CoT) and subsequent methods adopted a deductive paradigm that decomposes the reasoning process, demonstrating remarkable performances across NLP tasks. However, such a paradigm faces the challenge of getting bogged down in low-level semantic details, hindering large language models (LLMs) from correctly understanding, selecting, and compositing conditions. In this work, we present Overarching Prompting (OaP), a simple prompting method that elicits the high-level thinking of LLMs. Specifically, OaP first abstracts the whole problem into a simplified archetype and formulates strategies grounded in concepts and principles, establishing an overarching perspective for guiding reasoning. We conducted experiments with SoTA models, including ChatGPT, InstructGPT, and Llama3-70B-instruct, and received promising performances across tasks including Knowledge QA, Mathematical, and Open-Domain Reasoning. For instance, OaP improved ChatGPT and CoT by 19.0% and 3.1% on MMLU’s College Physics, 8.8% and 2.3% on GSM8k, and 10.3% and 2.5% on StrategyQA, respectively.