Complete Graphical Criterion for Sequential Covariate Adjustment in Causal Inference

Abstract

Covariate adjustment, also known as back-door adjustment, is a fundamental tool in causal inference. Although a sound and complete graphical identification criterion, known as the adjustment criterion (Shpitser, 2010), exists for static contexts, sequential contexts present challenges. Current practices, such as the sequential back-door adjustment (Pearl, 1995) or multi-outcome sequential back-door adjustment (Jung, 2020), are sound but incomplete; i.e., there are graphical scenarios where the causal effect is expressible via covariate adjustment, yet these criteria do not cover. In this paper, we exemplify this incompleteness and then present the *sequential adjustment criterion*, a sound and complete criterion for sequential covariate adjustment. We provide a constructive sequential adjustment criterion that identifies a set that satisfies the sequential adjustment criterion if and only if the causal effect can be expressed as a sequential covariate adjustment. Finally, we present an algorithm for identifying a *minimal* sequential covariate adjustment set, which optimizes efficiency by ensuring that no unnecessary vertices are included.